Preventable or Not? – Excavator Bucket Hits Two People, Kills One

Safety Watch is an Equipment World feature that highlights a prior closed OSHA case and how the incident could have been prevented, to help improve jobsite safety. This story originally ran in August 2019.

The first day on any construction job is tough, but it shouldn’t have to be this tough.

The victim on this day was a 43-year-old construction laborer working for a masonry contractor. The job was to demolish and remove a concrete wheelchair ramp leading up to the side of a restaurant.

The victim had been standing on the ground helping to remove small pieces of debris as a compact excavator operator scooped up larger chunks.

When the bucket of the compact excavator got tangled up in the air lines of a compressor, the victim and a bystander, a woman who was a friend of the operator, stepped into the swing zone of the boom and bucket to see what the problem was. Hydraulic pressure on the boom, however, yanked the air hose free from its coupling at the compressor, and the boom and bucket jerked to the right. The operator overcompensated by pushing the controls to the left, which unfortunately caused the bucket to slam the victim and the woman against the side of the air compressor.

The victim suffered compression injuries but remained conscious. The woman suffered a laceration on her head but was not seriously harmed. After the excavator operator backed the bucket off, the coworker helped the victim to his truck and called 911.

Emergency medical responders transported both to the hospital, but while in transit, the victim became unresponsive and unstable. Emergency surgery was attempted, but the doctors could not stop the internal bleeding. He died the following morning about 10 hours after the incident.

According to state investigators, the general contractor did not have records showing evidence of a safety program or safety training.

How this accident could have been prevented:

  • Provide workers with safety training to help them recognize unsafe conditions and work practices.
  • Ensure that equipment operators have been trained in the safe operation of the equipment they are assigned to operate at the site.
  • Conduct daily jobsite hazard reviews before work starts in the morning. An analysis of this jobsite would have shown that the excavator and the compressor and its hoses should have been positioned out of each other’s way.
  • Take extra time to brief newcomers on the hazards of the jobsite. Experienced earthmoving crews know not to step into the swing radius of an excavator until the bucket is on the ground and the engine at idle. The victim and his coworker in this case obviously did not.     
Excavator bucket slams worker and bystander into air compressor
Between a bucket and a hard place

The operator overcompensated by pushing the controls to the left, which unfortunately caused the bucket to slam the victim and the woman against the side of the air compressor…

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

CaptureAugust
Worker injured by demolition robot

As he was moving the cable, he accidentally bumped the control panel against the machine. Since he had not put the machine into the emergency stop mode, it moved, pinning him bewteen the outrigger and a nearby wall…

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

CaptureJune
One lock, not enough

Investigators believe the victim raised the dump bed on the artic to access a grease zerk that was covered by the body of the bed when it was in the down position. During this procedure, the dump body should have been locked in the raised position…

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

CaptureApril
Brake Fail

The dozer rolled backward trapping the semi-truck driver between the truck’s front bumper and the rear of the dozer.

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

Screenshot_2018-08-20 SafetyWatch0718_ENG pdf
Attempt to disassemble crane boom proves fatal

Most safety precautions regarding cranes pertain to when the machine is in operation. But, the process of assembling or dismantling a crane can be fraught with danger.

 

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

screen-shot-2016-12-06-at-3-25-57-pm
Cold weather calamity: Attempt to clear ice from foot controls leads to operator’s death

The accident: On a cold January night in Michigan, the operator of a skid steer was getting ready to plow snow after a recent storm, when he noticed the foot controls weren’t operating properly.

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

screen-shot-2016-12-06-at-3-02-43-pm
Paving pitfalls: Workers should be on guard around moving machines

The accident: A skid-steer operator working on a paving project backed into a worker shoveling asphalt, pinning him between the skid steer and a paver, and crushing his legs between the pieces of equipment.

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

0115_Safety Watch_pix
PPE problems: When used incorrectly personal protective equipment can create a hazard

The accident: A backhoe operator jumped off his machine to assist another crewmember. The strap of his fall protection harness became entangled on the control levels, moving the loader bucket. The bucket crushed another worker between the bucket and a concrete building.

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

Safety Watch 46
Spotting safety problems: Always know what’s around you

The accident: A dump truck backed onto a site behind a skid steer. The skid steer operator failed to see a worker approaching the dump truck on foot, and backed into him, pinning him against the tailgate.

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

Safety Watch 43
Major miscalculations: When felling trees with an excavator, know when and where to dig

The accident: A worker using a hydraulic excavator to remove trees used a bucket to dig away from the base and then push the trunk over. A tree fell onto the excavator’s cab, pinning him inside.

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

Safety Watch 42
Not so fast: Before you attach a bucket, take a closer look at your quick coupler

The accident: During a water main installation, a crew member entered a newly dug lateral excavation, preparing to install pipe. Using a quick coupler, an excavator operator changed buckets and swung the machine over to the trench to continue digging on the main line. The bucket detached and fell into the excavation, killing the man in the trench.

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

Not_so_fast_image
A safe exit: Make sure you’ve locked out controls before leaving a cab for any reason

The accident: A man stopped to clear debris from a dozer, getting out of the cab. When the dozer started to move, he tried getting back behind the controls, but slipped off the machine and was crushed beneath it.

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

A_safe_exit_image
Danger zone: Stand clear of an excavator’s swing pivot area

The accident: A contractor was removing tree stumps on a road project and processing the stumps and other wood debris in a tub grinder. An excavator loaded the grinder, operated remotely by a worker on the ground.

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

dangerzone
Know your limits: Don’t work on equipment unless you have the proper training

The accident: An employee was repairing a 60-foot telescopic boom lift that had a malfunctioning counterbalance valve. He loosened the valve from underneath the rear of the lift and then climbed onto the lift’s base to access the valve from the front of the lift, positioning him directly under the boom.

Download English Version

knowyourlimits
Backhoe woes: Make sure your machine is blocked or chocked before leaving it on a slope

The accident: A backhoe operator was working on covering a pipe in a drainage ditch next to a retaining wall. He parked the machine on a slope and exited the backhoe while leaving the bucket, which was full of rocks and gravel, elevated.

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

backhoewoes
Don’t get pinned: Safe operation starts with the basics

The accident: The contractor instructed an excavator operator to move dirt, clear debris and fill a trench, and then left the jobsite. Upon his return, he saw the excavator – which was an older model that had been purchased used – positioned over the trench, with the operator pinned to a tree and crushed by the machine.

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

dontgetpinned
Off, not idling: If you leave a backhoe for any reason, make sure the machine is completely turned off

The accident: A two-man crew was using a backhoe loader and hand shovel to clear earth from a home’s foundation footing. The backhoe operator dug a 2-foot-wide by 2-foot-deep excavation around the footing while the second worker removed extra dirt with the shovel after the backhoe passed through…

Download English Version

Descargue la versión española

offnotidling
Page 1 of 2
Next Page